diff --git a/app/Helpers/custom.php b/app/Helpers/custom.php
index 71070e8..9343d11 100644
--- a/app/Helpers/custom.php
+++ b/app/Helpers/custom.php
@@ -779,9 +779,10 @@ if (!function_exists('formKriteria')) {
                         $option = json_decode($data->option);
                         $value = json_decode(@$penilaian->value);
                         $valueOld = json_decode(@$penilaianOld->value);
+                        dd(@$value);
                         
                         foreach($option as $keyOption => $dataOption){
-
+                            
                             if(@$value){
                                 if(in_array($dataOption, (is_array(@$value) ? @$value : array(@$value)))){
                                     $checked = 'checked';
@@ -795,7 +796,7 @@ if (!function_exists('formKriteria')) {
                             $key = 'number_'.$keyKriteria.'_'.$keyOption;
 
                             $html .= '<div class="custom-control custom-checkbox m-2">';
-                                $html .= '<input type="checkbox" '.(@$value == $dataOption ? 'checked' : (@$valueOld == $dataOption ? 'checked' : '') ).' class="custom-control-input is-required" id="'.$key.'" value="'.$dataOption.'" name="input_'.$data->key.'[]">';
+                                $html .= '<input type="checkbox" '.@$checked.' class="custom-control-input is-required" id="'.$key.'" value="'.$dataOption.'" name="input_'.$data->key.'[]">';
                                 $html .= '<label class="custom-control-label" for="'.$key.'">'.$dataOption.'</label>';
                             $html .= '</div>';
                         }